Gotham Lost and Found header image 1

7 West 46th Street

June 7th, 2009 by DavidFreeland

I’ve long been fascinated by this tall, somewhat foreboding house that sits to the west of Fifth Avenue at 7 West 46th Street – a block that, until very recently, offered one of midtown’s last uninterrupted stretches of 19th and early 20th-century buildings.  The block has also been known as “Little Brazil,” a tiny pocket of food and culture where the sounds of Portuguese mingle with Hebrew (the equally interesting Diamond District sits just one block to the north).  During the latter part of the 19th century it was an upper-class enclave, although many of its brownstones had been adapted for commercial purposes by the 1910s and 1920s.  7 West 46th is one of the few to have retained noteworthy elements of its original appearance.


Developers have cleared a number of sites to the west of the house, farther down 46th Street toward Sixth Avenue, but so far the building itself and its immediate neighbors appear to be secure from demolition.  Even so, this grand edifice bears signs of extensive interior alteration, as evidenced by the plywood boards covering the insides of the door and first-floor windows.  The contemporary metal-framed door itself is a defacement that almost seems barbaric, given the loveliness of its surroundings, and at the moment the entire house (with its sooty facade) looks to be uninhabited.

Perhaps the most striking feature of 7 West 46th Street, apart from its magnificent door cornice, is the animal sculpture placed atop the stoop.


Was it a design feature of the original house?  If not, when was it added and by whom?  Can it give us a clue into the identity of the house’s prior occupants?  My friend Amber, who was with me when I took these photographs, felt something very dark about the house, and there is certainly a melancholy aura surrounding it – although how much of that emanates from the recent defacements to which it has been subjected would be difficult to say.  Over the next week, let’s see how much of its story we can rescue.

Tags:   · 6 Comments

Leave a Comment

6 responses so far ↓

  • I just passed by this building and was also so intrigued, clearly, soon slated for demotion with a couple of other buildings nearby that have interesting stonework facades. Sad that we don’t treasure our history enough for preservation and renewal.

  • If I had read further I would have had some of my questions answered. Thank you. It’s too bad the city is tearing down most of it’s history. Downtown is almost all gone and now mid town is going also!

  • I have felt the same about the house. Does anyone know the history behind the house?

  • I walk past this house frequently and finally became intrigued enough to look it up online and found this blog, and the following tidbit.

    It seems that jazz pianist and composer Errol Garner recorded some of his early music here in 1944. A resident of the building was Timme Rosenkrantz, a Danish jazz lover and producer known as “the Jazz Baron”. Garner recorded some albums in his apartment, and the clincher is that there was an album entitled “7 West 46th Street” recorded in 1944 in the name of the “Errol Garner All Stars”,

  • Thanks for the info, Chris!

  • A New York Times article entitled “Helpful Hardware” printed on October 25, 1979 makes reference to 7 West 46th Street as Goldberg Marine Hardware store.